Conflicts of Interest

Layout for printing
Policy Number:
UW-4001
Responsible Office:
Office of Research Policy and Integrity

University Policy

Rationale/​Purpose:

It is the policy of UW–Madison to ensure that research is not biased in its design, conduct, or reporting, and to ensure especially the protection of human subjects, by requiring disclosure and review of certain outside activities, and where appropriate, by managing and reporting significant financial interests that might present a real or perceived conflict of interest with an individual's institutional responsibilities in such a manner as to appear to directly and significantly compromise the integrity of research.

Definitions:

The following definitions apply solely to the use of the terms in this policy and its attendant guidelines.

Business entity
Any corporation, partnership, proprietorship, firm, enterprise, franchise, association, trust, or legal entity other than an individual or body politic. This term also includes any entity acting as the agent of a business entity (e.g., a contract research organization). Business entities include both nonprofit and for-profit entities.
Fiduciary
A person holding the character of a trustee, or a character analogous to that of a trustee, in respect to the trust and confidence involved in it and the scrupulous good faith and candor which it requires. A person having duty, created by his undertaking, to act primarily for another's benefit in matters connected with such undertaking.
Financial conflict of interest (FCOI)
A significant financial interest that could directly and significantly affect the design, conduct, or reporting of federally funded research or research involving human subjects.
Human subject
A living individual about whom an investigator (whether professional or student) conducting research obtains data through intervention or interaction with the individual, or identifiable private information. (For definitions of intervention, interaction, and private information, see the Common Rule, 45 CFR 46.102).
Immediate family
An investigator's spouse and dependent children.
Institution
Any domestic or foreign, public or private, entity or organization (excluding a Federal agency) that is applying for, or that receives PHS research funding.
Institutional responsibilities
An investigator's professional responsibilities on behalf of UW–Madison, including research, research consultation, instruction, professional practice, extension/outreach, administrative activities, and institutional committee memberships.
Investigator
The principal investigator or project director and any individual (e.g., faculty member, staff member, student, fellow, or trainee, including those with zero percent appointments, or, as determined by inter-institutional agreements, collaborators or subrecipient awardees not employed by UW–Madison) who is responsible for the design, conduct, or reporting of research involving human subjects, federally funded research, or research proposed for federal funding.
Manage
Take action to address a conflict of interest, which can include reducing or eliminating the conflict of interest, to ensure to the extent possible that the design, conduct, and reporting of research will be free from bias.
Minimal risk
The probability and magnitude of harm or discomfort anticipated in the research are not greater in and of themselves than those ordinarily encountered in daily life or during the performance of routine physical or psychological examinations or tests.
Research
A systematic investigation designed to develop or contribute to generalizable knowledge. The term encompasses basic and applied research (e.g., that which results in a published article, book or book chapter) and product development (e.g., a diagnostic test or a drug).
Senior/key personnel
For the purposes of this policy, refers to the individuals engaged in federally funded research and means the Principal Investigator and any other person identified as senior/key personnel by UW–Madison in the grant application, progress report, or any other report submitted to the Public Health Service by UW–Madison under 42 C.F.R. Part 50, Subpart F.
Significant financial interest (SFI)
Any financial interest held by an investigator (and/or his or her immediate family), or by a business entity controlled or directed by the investigator or a member of his or her immediate family, that has monetary value, whether or not the value is readily ascertainable, including:
  • Remuneration
    • Publicly traded companies: (e.g., salary, consulting fees, honoraria, paid authorship, etc.) received from a publicly traded entity, including any foreign entities, in the twelve months preceding disclosure, and the value of any equity interest (stock, stock option, or other ownership interest) in the entity at the date of disclosure that, when aggregated, exceed $5,000.
    • Privately held companies: Remuneration, (e.g., salary, consulting fees, honoraria, paid authorship, etc.) received from a non-publicly traded entity, including any foreign entities, of greater than $5,000 in the twelve months preceding the disclosure.
  • Any equity interest (e.g., stock, stock option, or other ownership interest) in a non-publicly traded entity, including any foreign entities.
  • Royalty income from intellectual property rights not arising out of university employment, which are not assigned to organizations created to manage such rights on behalf of the University of Wisconsin–Madison.
  • Reimbursed or sponsored travel related to institutional responsibilities that is not reimbursed or sponsored by a U.S. government agency, a U.S. university, or an academic teaching hospital, medical center, or research institute that is affiliated with a U.S. university.
  • Service in positions with fiduciary responsibility, including senior managers (e.g., presidents, vice presidents, etc.) and members of boards of directors, whether or not the investigator receives compensation for such service.
Subrecipient
An entity or individual named on a subcontract from UW–Madison on a federally funded award or human subjects research proposal.
Technology
Any diagnostic, therapeutic, medical, or surgical procedure and any process, method, compound, drug, or device.
Scope:

This policy applies to investigators engaging in - or proposing to engage in - federally funded research or any research involving human subjects. Generally, the UW–Madison Conflict of Interest Committee does not review or manage outside activities of individuals who do not hold a UW–Madison appointment. However, in accord with Federal regulations, when UW–Madison carries out federally funded research through subcontractors, subrecipients, or collaborators, the terms of the agreement between the parties will dictate whether this policy or the policy of the other party applies to the subrecipient investigator(s).

Policy:

  1. Relationship to Similar Policies and Documents

    1. This policy operates in conjunction with other UW–Madison policies on conflict of interest that apply to all faculty members (see Faculty Policies and Procedures Chapter 8), members of the academic staff (see Academic Staff Policies and Procedures, Chapter 12), university officials (see policy governing Institutional Conflict of Interest Program), and university staff (see Regent Policy Document 20-22, Code of Ethics). UW–Madison has adopted this policy and its attendant guidelines to incorporate the requirements set forth in the regulations promulgated by the US Department of Health and Human Services (42 C.F.R. § 50, Subpart F and 45 C.F.R. § 94) and the National Science Foundation (NSF 510) to promote objectivity in research.
    2. Additional information about this policy's supporting processes and procedures is located in the Financial Conflict of Interest Policy and Procedures: Guidance Document.

  2. Background

    1. Generating new knowledge through research and translating that knowledge into applications that benefit society are important aspects of the mission of UW–Madison. The University encourages its faculty and staff to engage in research, to share their knowledge, and to promote the application of research results. Since these activities may result in financial gain to investigators, the UW–Madison, as a steward of public funds and the public trust, has the responsibility to identify those interactions that create potential conflicts of interest, and to manage those conflicts in a way that ensures the integrity of UW–Madison's core activities and values.

    2. According to the National Institutes of Health, a potential financial conflict of interest exists when an investigator has significant financial interests that could lead an independent observer to reasonably question whether the design, conduct, or reporting of research might be influenced by the possibility of personal gain to the individual or to his or her immediate family. Others define conflict of interest situations in terms of obligations. Two activities may interact such that judgment in one activity may be, or may seem to be, influenced by the other activity. Together, these two definitions identify important elements of conflicts of interest. Conflicts of interest:

      1. represent a state of affairs, not behavior,
      2. frequently involve perceptions, and
      3. are judged by others, not by those directly involved.

      Significant financial gains are considered to be of ultimate relevance in the current context for understanding conflicts of interest because money is recognized by the general public to be a potent motivator -- one that is easily understood, easily quantified, and discretionary. While the focus of conflict of interest considerations is financial gain, other relevant interests inherent in academia, including prestige, promotion, grants, and publications, can also potentially exert influence over research activities.

      Because financial conflicts of interest could contribute to bias in research reporting, influence judgment, reduce free exchange of research findings, pose a threat to research integrity, and compromise the protection of human subjects, UW–Madison has legal and ethical responsibilities to review and manage potential financial conflicts of interest in research.

      Furthermore, The University of Wisconsin–Madison receives funding from the U.S. Government that requires the University to comply with Federal Acquisition Regulations (FAR), Defense Federal Acquisition Regulations, and other contractual requirements. The purpose of these requirements is to assure impartial assistance, promote objectivity in research, prevent unfair competitive advantage, and protect proprietary or sensitive information received by the recipients of federal funding.

      Employees of the university may act in a capacity that provides them with access to proprietary data of the Government or may provide the Government with scientific or technical direction; analysis, assistance, advisory, or evaluation services; preparatory specifications or work statements while carrying out their university responsibilities.

      An organizational conflict of interest (OCI) may exist when access to the types of privileged information described above may prevent University of Wisconsin–Madison from providing impartial assistance or advice to research sponsors, impair its objectivity in performing research, or give an unfair competitive advantage in competition for Government funding.

  3. Requirements

    1. Training

      1. Investigators must undergo training on conflict of interest regulations, as well as UW–Madison's policy and guidelines, prior to the expenditure of funds in any federally funded research or participation in human subjects research. Training must be renewed at least every four years thereafter. Investigators who come to UW–Madison from other institutions must undergo UW–Madison's training prior to the expenditure of funds on a federally funded research project or participation in human subjects research. Retraining will be necessary should UW–Madison revise either its policy or guidelines concerning conflicts of interests in a manner that impacts the requirements of investigators, or in instances of noncompliance with this policy or a management plan.

    2. Disclosure

      1. Investigators engaging in, or proposing to engage in, federally funded research or research involving human subjects are required to report all significant financial interests held by themselves or their immediate families that reasonably appear to be related to the investigator's institutional responsibilities.
      2. Significant financial interests are to be reported on Outside Activities Reports annually, and must be completed no later than the time of application for federally funded research. In addition, investigators must update their Outside Activities Reports within 30 days of acquiring or discovering a new significant financial interest.
      3. Investigators conducting research involving human subjects must submit information to IRBs in accordance with the guidelines. In addition, if it has been determined that: (1) a collaborator employed at another institution will be following their institution’s PHS compliant FCOI policy, (2) the collaborating institution either (a) is a sponsor of the study or (b) owns or licenses a technology used in the study, and (3) the study is reviewed by a UW-Madison IRB or includes a proposal that the collaborator interact with UW-Madison participants, the collaborator must disclose the interests that they have in their institution (e.g., remuneration or equity) to the UW COI program for review and management.
      4. Investigators receiving funding from the federal agencies must also disclose the occurrence of travel reimbursed or sponsored by an outside organization, including all foreign entities. Per NIH Guide Notice NOT-OD-13-004, Investigators' initial disclosures must include all reimbursed and sponsored travel over the previous twelve-month period. After the initial disclosure, Investigators are required to update Outside Activities Reports within 30 days of such travel. As with other significant financial interests, this travel disclosure requirement also applies to reimbursed or sponsored travel by members of an Investigator's immediate family. This disclosure requirement includes all foreign entities, including academic institutions, but does not apply to travel that is reimbursed or sponsored by a U.S. Federal, state, or local government agency, a U.S. institution of higher education, a U.S. academic teaching hospital or a medical center, or a research institute that is affiliated with a U.S. institution of higher education.

    3. Review and Management of Relationships with External Entities

      1. UW–Madison has an obligation to manage any financial conflicts of interest as part of ensuring the integrity of research and protection of human subjects. To meet this obligation, the University directs the COI Committee to review all annual Outside Activities Reports, updates to such reports, and any protocol-specific Outside Activities Reports made by researchers conducting or proposing to conduct federally funded research or conducting research involving human subjects, to implement management plans, and to recommend appropriate actions to manage any financial conflicts of interest to reviewing IRBs. If an activity meets the definition of SFI, the COI Office makes a recommendation of management or no management. It then assigns at least one COI Committee member to review the reported activity and recommendation from the COI Office in preparation for further discussion at the next COI Committee Meeting. During the review, the COI Committee member (1) determines whether there is a nexus between an investigator's research and the significant financial interest; (2) determines whether a financial conflict of interest (FCOI) exists; and (3) notes whether they agree with the COI Office's management recommendation. The full committee then votes by simple majority to confirm the recommendation or suggest a change. If it is determined by the committee that an FCOI exists, a management plan is assigned to an investigator that specifies actions that have been, or will be, taken to manage the FCOI. A significant financial interest is a financial conflict of interest when the significant financial interest could directly and significantly have a material effect on the design, conduct, or reporting of research. Reviewers may consider the stage of the research, its commercial potential, magnitude of risk to participants in studies, and other factors when making a determination about the existence of a financial conflict of interest.
      2. UW Madison faculty, staff, and students with a management plan for an external entity cannot serve as an investigator on a human subjects protocol considered by a reviewing IRB to pose greater than minimal risk to research participants if the managed entity (a) sponsors the study, or (b) owns or licenses a technology used in the study.
        1. An investigator may apply to the COI Committee for an exception to this prohibition based on compelling circumstances.
        2. If a reviewing IRB determines that a study poses no greater than minimal risks to subjects, investigators will generally be permitted to participate in the study subject to limitations set forth in the conflict of interest management plan.
        3. A reviewing IRB has the authority to impose additional requirements that the IRB determines necessary to protect research participants.
      3. An individual who is engaged in human subjects research in collaboration with UW-Madison but is not employed by UW-Madison or enrolled at the University may not serve as an investigator on a human subjects protocol reviewed by a UW-Madison IRB or involving interaction with UW-Madison participants if they have an interest in an entity that (a) sponsors the study, or (b) owns or licenses a technology used in the study, without a management plan issued by the UW COI Committee. Such interests include significant financial interests as defined above, and include remuneration from or equity interests in their employer.

    4. Data Analysis and Publication

      1. Under no circumstances may a business entity limit the rights of an investigator to receive, analyze, or interpret any data generated as part of a research project. UW–Madison also prohibits restrictions on publication of research results, regardless of research outcomes. An investigator may agree to delay publication for the purpose of pre-publication review for a period consistent with that allowed by other UW–Madison policies (typically less than 30 days).

    5. Students, Fellows, Trainees, and Other Research Workers

      1. Significant financial interests may give rise to conflicts with an investigator's responsibility to foster the academic and professional development of students, fellows, trainees, or other research workers. An investigator's financial relationship with a business entity may not place restrictions on the activities of students or trainees. In particular, an investigator's relationship may not prevent or inhibit students or trainees from meeting applicable UW–Madison degree requirements (e.g., completion and public defense of a thesis or dissertation).
      2. Investigators must inform students engaged in research under their supervision of any financial interest which the investigator has in the research activity, including, but not limited to, financial arrangements involved in the direct support of the activity, agreements made by the investigator to obtain data for the research, or agreements concerning copyright or patent rights arising from the research.

    6. Payments from Business Entities

      1. UW–Madison prohibits payments to individuals from university accounts or directly or indirectly from business entities for particular research results or for research outcomes related to human subject protocols conducted at or through UW–Madison. Further, neither investigators nor their immediate families may receive any personal incentives from university accounts or directly or indirectly from business entities, such as recruitment incentives, performance incentives, fellowships, or other research support, except through an agreement entered into by the university for sponsored research. The UW–Madison only permits payments for subject enrollment, or for the referral of potential subjects to human subjects studies, when all of the following are present:
        1. The payment reasonably relates to costs incurred, as specified in research agreements between the sponsor and the UW–Madison.
        2. The payment reflects the fair market value of services performed.
        3. The payment is commensurate with the efforts of the investigator(s) performing the research. More information on review and management is available in the guidelines that accompany this policy.

    7. Public accessibility of information concerning individuals receiving funding from the Public Health Service

      1. In accordance with Federal regulations, certain information about identified conflicts of interest of investigators who are named as senior/key personnel on research funded by the Public Health Service must be made available to the public.

    8. Reports to Funding Agencies

      1. As a condition of eligibility to receive grants or cooperative agreements for research from the Public Health Service, UW–Madison must provide reports on financial conflicts of interest to the appropriate PHS Awarding Component in the time and manner specified in the regulations and outlined in the Guidance Document.

    9. Reconsideration of COI Committee Decisions

      1. An investigator may request reconsideration of any COI Committee determination that affects his or her ability to participate, or conditions of participation, in federally funded or human subjects research. Investigators have twenty (20) business days from receipt of notification from the COI Committee or a UW–Madison IRB conveying the determination to request reconsideration. Individuals must make requests in writing and direct them to the Associate Vice Chancellor for Research Policy and Integrity.

    10. Ongoing Monitoring

      1. UW–Madison monitors compliance with management plans on an ongoing basis.

    11. Noncompliance

      1. Deliberate misrepresentation of information to the COI Committee or an IRB or failure to comply with the terms of this policy or a management plan may result in sanctions including disciplinary actions up to and including termination and/or loss of privilege to serve as an investigator on federally funded research projects or human subjects research protocols.
      2. In the case of research funded by the Public Health Service, instances of noncompliance trigger additional obligations of UW–Madison to the PHS Awarding Component.
      3. In such situations, UW–Madison must follow the appropriate reporting and review processes detailed in the Guidance Document.
      4. In any case in which the Department of Health and Human Services determines that a PHS-funded project of clinical research whose purposes is to evaluate the safety or effectiveness of a drug, medical device, or treatment has been designed, conducted, or reported by an investigator with a financial conflict of interest that was not managed or reported as required by federal regulations, the Investigator shall be required to disclose the FCOI in each public presentation of the results of the research and to request an addendum to previously published presentations to indicate the existence of the FCOI.

    12. Records Retention

      1. UW–Madison must maintain records of all financial disclosures and all actions taken with respect to any conflict of interest covered by this policy for at least three years from the date of submission of the final expenditures report or, where applicable, from other dates specified in 45 C.F.R. § 75.361(b).

  4. Financial Interests Arising from Ordinary Professional Activities

    1. Significant financial interests do not include the following:
      1. Salary, royalties, or other remuneration received from UW–Madison, the University of Wisconsin Medical Foundation, or the Veterans Administration (VA).
      2. Royalty income from intellectual property rights arising out of UW–Madison employment that are assigned to organizations created to manage such rights on behalf of the University of Wisconsin–Madison.
      3. Income from investment vehicles, such as mutual funds and retirement accounts, as long as the investigator does not control the investment decisions made in these vehicles.
      4. Income from seminars, lectures, or teaching engagements sponsored by a domestic government agency, a university, an academic teaching hospital, a medical center, or a research institute that is affiliated with a university.
      5. Income from service on advisory committees or review panels for a domestic government agency, a university, an academic teaching hospital, a medical center, or a research institute that is affiliated with a university.
      6. Travel related to institutional responsibilities that is reimbursed or sponsored by a domestic government agency, a university, an academic teaching hospital, a medical center, or a research institute that is affiliated with a university.

  5. Organizational Conflicts of Interest

    1. Responsibilities of Office of the Vice Chancellor for Research (OVCR)

      1. When a contract or agreement invoking OCI terms is presented to the University, the OVCR Office of Research Policy and the department, institute, or center where the work will be done shall develop a Conflict-of-Interest attestation plan that will identify:
        1. a) participants in the proposed work; b) competitive contracts or agreements already within the department, institute or center; c) training needed for participants in university- and unit-level procedures for handling of sensitive and proprietary information; d) existing contracts or agreements that may generate competitive advantage to other parties through unequal access to information, may impair the objectivity of work carried out on the proposed or existing contracts or agreements, or may provide an opportunity to contribute to procurement rules for future projects; e) needs for participant recusal from such competitive contracts; and f) information to be included in non-disclosure agreements for participants.

      2. The attestation plan will be presented to all participants in the contract or agreement by representatives of the OVCR Office of Research Policy and leadership of the department, institute or center for review and signature before work can proceed. Copies of the signed attestation will be provided to the requesting sponsor, OVCR Office of Research Policy, the department, institute or center, and the participant.

        The leadership of the department, institute or center will provide a bi-annual report on status of compliance with the attestation plan to the OVCR Office of Research Policy.

        Ongoing after the enactment of an OCI attestation plan, the leadership of the department, institute or center will provide assessments of newly proposed contracts and their relevance to existing attestation plans. If potential OCI concerns are identified, the leadership will enact additional measures to prevent University of Wisconsin–Madison from providing impartial assistance or advice to research sponsors, impair its objectivity in performing research, or give an unfair competitive advantage in competition for Government funding.

    2. Responsibilities of the Unclassified Staff

      1. Among other things, UWS 8 prohibits members of the unclassified staff from using their university position for personal or private benefit in a manner contrary to the interests of the University of Wisconsin System and requires the disclosure of potential conflicts, including those that may generate organizational conflicts of interest.
      2. The unclassified staff must disclose outside professional activities that may result in an OCI. These activities are recognized to fall under broader institutional considerations for reporting and managing professional conflicts of interest described in the policies cited above. These activities include, but are not limited to, work done on behalf of the U.S. Government involving:
        1. contracts to provide scientific, engineering, and technical direction;
        2. serving as an advisor and providing analysis, assistance, or evaluation services;
        3. preparing specifications and work statements for funding opportunities;
        4. access to proprietary, confidential, or sensitive data.
      3. These activities may be undertaken in someone’s UW–Madison capacity, as an independent contractor, or as a volunteer. Disclosure of compensation received (if any) and time committed to these outside professional activities must be made using the on-line UW–Madison’s Outside Activities Reporting process and disclosed to Research and Sponsored Programs, and as part of grant application or contracting efforts involving the unclassified staff member and a federal sponsor of research.
      4. In the event a potential OCI is identified that is related to proposed or ongoing research at the university, a representative of the OVCR will work with Research and Sponsored Programs, the Government’s contracting officer/program manager, the impacted UW–Madison personnel and their departments and others as necessary to neutralize or mitigate the OCI.
      5. Management of the OCI may include participant recusal from certain activities, maintaining confidentiality of data, review of work by an independent third party, or others.
Related UW-Madison Policies:
Related UW–Madison Documents, Web Pages, or Other Resources:
External References:

Policy Administration

Approval Authority:
Vice Chancellor for Research
Policy Manager:
Associate Vice Chancellor for Research Policy and Integrity
Contact:
Conflict of Interest Compliance Program -- Conflict of Interest Compliance Program, coiprogram@research.wisc.edu
Effective Date:
08-23-2012
Revised Dates:

11-24-2020, 01-22-2021, 08-28-2023, 10-25-2023

Retrieved:
01-12-2025 15:26:52